It brings an end to the four-year battle to save the tree which came after insurers claimed it risked damaging nearby homes, reports James Cracknell

Environmental campaigners in Haringey are celebrating the news that a 120-year-old tree – threatened with the chop for the past four years – has now been saved.
Insurance companies had long wanted to remove the plane tree in Oakfield Road, Stroud Green, over claims it was creating a subsidence risk to nearby properties.
The former Labour administration at Haringey Council agreed with those claims and decided in 2022 to chop it down, but this led to a determined effort from campaign group Haringey Tree Protectors to save what they considered to be an important ecological asset for the local area.
The environmental group claimed the tree’s removal was unnecessary and that the insurers should pay to underpin the properties.
In 2023, after winning an injunction against the protestors, the council built a “scaffolding fortress” around the tree and paid for guards to prevent protestors from “occupying” it. But it later emerged that this security operation had cost more than £90,000.
Then, in 2024, a court ruled that the council was lawfully permitted to remove the tree.
But Haringey Tree Protectors always argued there was no evidence that the tree was the direct and primary cause of subsidence and that an engineering solution should be found, instead of the plan to remove the tree.
Once the group’s legal avenues had been exhausted, one of the homeowners pursued his own case believing that the subsidence would only be solved once the building was properly underpinned.
Following two financial ombudsman rulings that the insurers should pay to underpin the affected building, the firms finally agreed.
Despite the agreement to underpin, the council again proposed to bring in the chainsaws in 2025, fearing that it could still be subject to legal action if any nearby property suffered subsidence.
However, the work never happened, and in May this year the eco-conscious Green Party took control of Haringey Council, with Labour removed from office in the borough for the first time since the 1970s.
The new Green administration has now decided to leave the tree in place and manage the tree in line with the other plane trees on the street.
A recent decision notice explained that the council would “implement a suitable risk mitigation strategy for the tree in line with its
approach to risk management, including pruning to support the future risk mitigation strategy”.
It also pointed out that the 2025 consultation drew significant objections to the removal of the tree.
In a statement this week, Haringey Tree Protectors welcomed the decision.
They said: “Mature trees are essential for our survival in the current climate crisis. They cool streets, reducing the heat island effect, provide shelter from sun and rain, improve air quality, disperse flood water, are vital habitat for wildlife and biodiversity, and improve local residents’ mental health.
“Subsidence is a complex issue and cases are accelerating due to our increasingly hot and dry summers, caused by the changing climate. Many late Victorian/Edwardian houses such as this one [in Oakfield Road] were built with very shallow foundations.
“More and more houses will be impacted by subsidence in North London, which is on clay soil, whether they are near trees or not.
“Haringey Tree Protectors was established by a group of local residents to monitor and protect both trees and green spaces in the borough. We argue that mature trees should be treated as critical infrastructure and should be properly protected.”
Local news needs your support
We are proud that we were at the forefront of reporting on the recent local elections. We can’t do this without the support of our readers.
Independent news outlets like ours – reporting for the community without rich backers – are under threat of closure, turning British towns into news deserts.
If our coverage has helped you understand our community a little bit better, please consider supporting us with a monthly, yearly or one-off donation.
ACT NOW!
Monthly direct debit












Enjoying Haringey Community Press? You can help support our not-for-profit news website from £5 per month.